Former Prime Minister declares that no member state has the right to whittle away the four founding principles of Caribbean sovereignty
KINGSTON, Jamaica — November 17, 2026: Former Prime Minister the Most Hon. P.J. Patterson has delivered a blunt warning to the leaders of the Caribbean Community: the region is abandoning the principles on which its sovereignty was built, and it is doing so at the most dangerous moment in CARICOM’s history.
“We are moving in the wrong direction,” Mr Patterson told a capacity audience at the University of the West Indies, Mona, on Sunday, November 15, at the launch of Caribbean Integration: The Patterson Doctrine — Governance, Transformation and the Future of the Caribbean Community, by Professor Sir Kenneth Hall and Myrtle Chuck-A-Sang.
Mr Patterson, who served at ministerial level as the region moved from CARIFTA to a common market and then to the Caribbean Community, reminded the audience that the integration movement rests on the work of the four leaders of the then independent states — Eric Williams, Michael Manley, Forbes Burnham and Errol Barrow — and on four fundamental principles they enshrined at Chaguaramas:
–that sovereignty means equality for all, and is most effective when exercised collectively;
–that the Caribbean is to be a zone of peace;
–that the rule of international law must be obeyed; and
–that every people has the right to self-determination.
“These are the four fundamental principles enshrined at Chaguaramas, and they are embedded in the DNA of the Caribbean Community,” he said. “And without casting stones at anyone, I would say no member nation of the Community has the right to whittle away any of those fundamental principles.”
A zone of peace, not a battleground
Mr Patterson credited Eric Williams with leading the argument for a zone of peace, recalling Dr Williams’s observation that European powers had fought more wars in the Caribbean than on the continent of Europe itself. The founders, he said, were determined that the region would never again be the arena for other people’s conflicts.
He was equally direct on why international law is a matter of survival, not sentiment, for small states: “For those of us who were small and, in terms of military might, weak, we had no other source on which to rely.”
“Nothing before has been like this”
The former Prime Minister acknowledged that changes of government and ideological differences are a natural product of the Caribbean’s democratic traditions, and that the Community has survived severe shocks before.
“Grenada, and the invasion of it in 1983, nearly crushed the Community once and for all,” he said. “But nothing before has been like the seismic convulsions we are witnessing today.”
He described it as “a matter of profound sadness” that the currents now sweeping the region are driving its members apart rather than binding them together.
Exorcise the federal ghost
Mr Patterson called on the region to stop looking backward. “For six decades we have been haunted by the federal ghost,” he said, insisting that it must now be exorcised once and for all. Global turbulence, he argued, leaves the Caribbean one choice: to be of good courage and move forward to “a mature, resilient and vibrant regionalism.”
He also demanded urgency from the CARICOM committee on governance and finance, established to make the Community fit for purpose: “That committee needs to get to work, and now.”
Africa and the next generation
Pointing to what he termed the hegemonic “Donroe Doctrine,” Mr Patterson said the times compel the Caribbean “to establish meaningful links with global Africa.” He disclosed that he is working with colleagues on the African continent on the design of a global African coalition embracing governments and peoples across Africa’s six regions and the diaspora.
He closed with a direct challenge to the faculty and students of the UWI: “to be the vanguards of the change we need” and to help fashion a dynamic Caribbean Community.
Mr Patterson then introduced the guest speaker, Prime Minister of Barbados the Hon. Mia Amor Mottley, whom he hailed as “the gem from Barbados, the jewel of the Caribbean.”
The message from Mona is unmistakable. The four principles are not relics. They are the only shield small states have ever had — and the man who helped build CARICOM has served notice that they are not any one government’s to give away.